Week 34:
Goodnight
Goon: A Petrifying Parody VS Otis and the Scarecrow
Goodnight
Goon: A Petrifying Parody:
Summary:
Goodnight
monsters everywhere, in this parody romp with its own special twist!
Goodnight
tomb. Goodnight goon. Goodnight Martians taking over the moon.?
It's bedtime
in the cold gray tomb with a black lagoon, and two slimy claws, and a couple of
jaws, and a skull and a shoe and a pot full of goo. But as a little werewolf
settles down, in comes the Goon determined at all costs to run amok and not let
any monster have his rest.
A beloved
classic gets a kind-hearted send up in this utterly monsterized parody;
energetic art and a hilarious text will have kids begging to read this again
and again.
Review:
I've come to realize I don't really like rhyming stories. This book has
great illustrations and it really fit with its style being a Halloween book,
however I found it a little hard to care for the story. It was kinda fun in ways, but
overall it lacked the "it" factor.
Otis and the Scarecrow:
Summary:
On the farm
where Otis the tractor lives, the farmer has introduced someone new—a scarecrow
to shoo away the pesky crows. But when Otis and the animals greet the scarecrow
with friendly smiles, the scarecrow’s frown never leaves his face. So everyone
leaves him alone.
Then one day, when a cold autumn rain sets in, Otis and the animals snuggle close and play Otis’s favorite game: the quiet game. Otis knows the puppy and ducks can’t sit still for long, and soon the farm friends begin to giggle and squirm, feeling warmed by one another’s friendship . . . but on this day, Otis can't seem to take his eyes off the lonely figure in the cornfield.
Then one day, when a cold autumn rain sets in, Otis and the animals snuggle close and play Otis’s favorite game: the quiet game. Otis knows the puppy and ducks can’t sit still for long, and soon the farm friends begin to giggle and squirm, feeling warmed by one another’s friendship . . . but on this day, Otis can't seem to take his eyes off the lonely figure in the cornfield.
A deeply resonant book about subtle acts of compassion and standing up for others, featuring everyone's favorite tractor, Otis.
Review:
I really wanted to like this book. I loved the other "Otis" book
that I reviewed months ago, but this one was simply not that interesting. And it was long. It seemed like
it was building a good character in the scarecrow, but in the end it
didn't really deliver as I had hoped it would.
The Winner:
Congratulations
to Otis and the Scarecrow!
We will see you in November!
We’ll see
everyone else next week!